OpenTipJar Blog • Comparison

OpenTipJar vs eTip: A Real-World Comparison from a Hyatt Hotel Stay

By •

Side-by-side comparison of two digital tipping checkout experiences: one with a visible service fee prompt versus a simple, fee-free guest flow

While traveling recently, I came across a digital tipping setup inside a hotel room at a Hyatt Place. On the surface, it looked exactly like what we're building with OpenTipJar — a simple QR code that lets guests leave a tip for the room attendant team.

Naturally, I had to try it.

What I found was interesting — and highlights a key difference in how digital tipping platforms approach pricing, user experience, and transparency. Enterprise tools like eTip often layer a monthly subscription on top of per-transaction fees and pass costs to guests at checkout. OpenTipJar takes a different path: no monthly fee, just 5% + $0.40 per tip, absorbed by the business so guests never see an extra charge.


📸 What the Experience Looked Like

A small in-room sign invited me to scan a QR code to leave a gratuity. After scanning, I landed on a clean tipping page with preset amounts ($5, $10, $20) and a checkout experience powered by Apple Pay or card.

So far, so good.

But then I noticed something important.


💳 The "Service Fee" Moment

Before completing the tip, there was a checkbox:

"Cover the $X service fee so it all goes to the Room Attendant Team"

Here's what those fees looked like:

  • $5 tip → $0.65 fee
  • $10 tip → $0.99 fee
  • $20 tip → $1.68 fee

That means the platform is adding roughly:

~3% + $0.50–$1.10 per transaction

But more importantly:

👉 The fee is being pushed to the guest — not the business


⚖️ OpenTipJar vs eTip (Side-by-Side)

Here's how that compares to OpenTipJar:

OpenTipJar

  • No monthly fee — you only pay when guests tip
  • 5% + $0.40 per transaction (all-in, including payment processing)
  • Paid by the account holder, not the guest
  • No extra charges shown at checkout

eTip (based on real-world use)

  • Enterprise platform — typically sold with a monthly subscription
  • ~3% + $0.50–$1.10 per transaction
  • Often presented as a "service fee" to the guest
  • Pricing is not publicly listed (requires sales/demo)

📊 Real Numbers Comparison

The table below compares per-transaction fees only. OpenTipJar has no monthly subscription — you pay 5% + $0.40 only when a guest actually tips.

Tip AmountOpenTipJar FeeeTip FeeWho Pays
$5$0.65$0.65OTJ: Business / eTip: Guest
$10$0.90$0.99OTJ: Business / eTip: Guest
$20$1.40$1.68OTJ: Business / eTip: Guest

👉 On a per-tip basis, OpenTipJar is equal or cheaper — and there's no monthly subscription on top of that.


🧠 The Biggest Difference Isn't Price — It's Experience

Both platforms enable digital tipping.

But they handle the moment of payment very differently.

With eTip:

  • Guest selects tip
  • Then sees: "Do you want to cover the fee?"
  • Has to make a second decision

With OpenTipJar:

  • Guest selects tip
  • Completes payment
  • Done

No friction. No awkward upsell. No second guessing.


💡 Why This Matters

Tipping is emotional and often spontaneous.

Every extra step — especially one that introduces cost — creates hesitation.

That hesitation can lead to:

  • Lower tip completion rates
  • Smaller tip amounts
  • A less positive experience overall

🔍 Transparency Matters Too

Another key difference:

  • OpenTipJar pricing is simple and public: no monthly fee, just 5% + $0.40 per tip
  • eTip requires contacting sales for pricing — often bundled as an enterprise subscription

For small businesses, creators, and independent professionals, that difference matters.

You shouldn't need a demo just to start accepting tips.


🚀 A Different Philosophy

At OpenTipJar, we made a deliberate choice:

No monthly platform fee. Let the business absorb the per-tip cost so the tipping experience stays simple.

That means:

  • Guests never feel like they're being charged to tip
  • The experience stays clean and intuitive
  • Businesses pay only when they earn tips — no monthly platform fee
  • Per-transaction costs stay predictable: 5% + $0.40, all-in

🧾 Final Thoughts

Seeing another platform in the wild — especially in a large hotel — was a great validation of the space.

Digital tipping is here to stay.

But how it's implemented makes all the difference.

If you're evaluating options, ask yourself:

  • Do I want my customers to see extra fees at checkout?
  • Do I want a frictionless tipping experience?
  • Do I want pay-per-tip pricing, or a monthly subscription on top of transaction fees?
  • Do I want transparent pricing or a sales process?

Because those choices directly impact how often people actually complete a tip.


💬 Want to Try OpenTipJar?

You can set up your own digital tip page in minutes:

👉

No monthly fee. No contracts. No demos. No surprises.

Just a simple way for people to support you.


Create your tip page

Set up in minutes — no monthly fee, just 5% + $0.40 per tip, with no guest-facing fee prompts.